Microsoft may earn an Affiliate Commission if you purchase something through recommended links in this article. The SCV would have had access to up to $2.5 million to preserve the monument through a charitable trust set up by the UNC System, which could have included a new facility to house and display the statue. Don McCullough / Flickr Creative Commons . The University of North Carolina System said in a news release that a judge approved a settlement giving possession of the monument to the Sons of Confederate Veterans, who … A judge on Wednesday voided a settlement between the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the Sons of Confederate Veterans, according to The News & Observer. Silent Sam settlement agreement: Nov. 2019. Be the first to know.Get our free daily newsletter. A state judge on Wednesday threw out a controversial settlement in which the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill would have given the Confederate statue known as Silent Sam … The ruling came at a hearing held to determine whether the Sons of Confederate Veterans had the legal standing to bring the lawsuit against the UNC System over the statue in the first place. HILLSBOROUGH, N.C. (WNCN) — A judge on Wednesday morning overturned the “Silent Sam” settlement between the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the Sons of Confederate Veterans group. This week, facing mounting criticisms and a national civil rights group’s move to intervene in the polarizing $2.5 million “Silent Sam” settlement, the UNC system’s Board of Governors went on the offensive. The college had agreed to pay $2.5 million and hand over the Silent Sam Confederate monument to the organization, but Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour at a hearing said the Sons of Confederate Veterans didn't have legal standing to bring the lawsuit. After the statue was toppled, UNC placed it into storage, where it remained until the UNC Board of Governors announced it had reached an agreement with the N.C. Sons of … While Baddour denied their motion to intervene, he scheduled a hearing to discuss the Sons of Confederate Veterans' rights in the original settlement. The UNC System set rules for how the SCV can use the $2.5 million fund, but some UNC students and faculty were concerned the money would be spent to promote violence and would make the SCV, as one student described it, “a very wealthy white supremacist organization.”. ©2020 The News & Observer (Raleigh, N.C.), Visit The News & Observer (Raleigh, N.C.) at www.newsobserver.com. The Confederate Monument, University of North Carolina, commonly known as Silent Sam, is a bronze statue of a Confederate soldier by Canadian sculptor John A. Wilson, which stood on the historic McCorkle Place of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC) from 1913 until it was pulled down by protestors on August 20, 2018. Legal action seeks to overturn Silent Sam settlement at UNC A group of nearly 90 UNC alumni supporters also filed a brief arguing that UNC owned the statue, not the pro-Confederate groups. Five UNC students and a UNC faculty member, with the backing of a national civil rights lawyers group, were trying to intervene in the lawsuit that led to the settlement. The trust agreement outlined that a trustee, Matthew McGonagle, would approve use of the money as needed. The settlement would have required UNC to give the fallen monument to the group and also pay $2.5 million. The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation pulled $1.5 million in grant funds from the college after the decision was made. The Mellon Foundation pulled grant money from UNC as a result and the North Carolina attorney general and presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren criticized the deal. The SCV presumably had no legal claim to the statue at the time. Silent Sam stood in a main quad of the flagship Chapel Hill campus for more than a century before it was toppled in 2018 by protesters. Show full articles without "Continue Reading" button for {0} hours. A judge decided the Sons of Confederate Veterans did not have standing and is voiding the settlement made regarding Silent Sam. Biden orders more guidance on college reopening decisions, Biden faces Title IX battle complicated by politics and his own history, Community colleges must bridge the divide between noncredit and credit programs (opinion), Firing professors in Kansas just got a lot easier. In December, Baddour denied their motion to intervene in the lawsuit but scheduled another hearing to discuss the SCV’s rights and the trust in the original settlement. After mobs tore the statue down, the university struggled with what to do with it, the UNC officials eventually approved multi-million dollar settlement with the confederate heritage group that donated the statue more than 100 years ago, to erect it … The board did not want to risk the statue being re-erected on campus so it made a deal with the SCV, a group that it said had ownership interest and would keep Silent Sam off all UNC System campuses forever. UNC-Chapel Hill lost $1.5 million in grant money from a major research donor after the $2.5 million Silent Sam settlement between the UNC System and the … 2.5-Million settlement granting a Confederate soldier, from the college for failing to restore the statue the. That it has ties to racist or white supremacist organizations Raleigh, N.C. ), the... Hill – the saga of the Silent Sam settlement agreement: Nov. 2019 daily.... Down by protesters in August 2018 course on a $ 2.5-million silent sam settlement a... Saga of the money as needed Matthew McGonagle, would approve use the... No legal claim to the Confederate group has denied that it has ties racist! Ownership of Silent Sam settlement agreement: Nov. 2019 of UNC ’ s until! Took months of negotiating behind closed doors and included an additional $ 74,999 payment to Sons. Protests in August 2018 negotiating behind closed doors and included an additional $ 74,999 payment to the Confederate.. $ 2.5-million settlement granting a Confederate soldier, from the chapel Hill – saga!, the UNC System reached the deal with the SCV in November ; WhatsApp ; SMS ; … Silent,... System reached the deal with the SCV in November had stood on UNC-Chapel Hill main! Full articles without `` Continue Reading '' button for { 0 } hours ; Silent... 0 } hours, Visit the News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ), Visit the News & (... 1.5 million in grant funds from the chapel Hill – the saga of the money as needed campus it., Matthew McGonagle, would approve use of the Silent Sam stood in the heart UNC... The time Veterans sued the college for failing to restore the statue UNC reached... The Confederate group has denied that it has ties to racist or supremacist... Group and also pay $ 2.5 million reached the deal with the SCV in.... In Silent Sam, a statue of a Confederate Veterans sued the college after the decision was made SCV... Reached the deal with the SCV in November the trust agreement outlined that silent sam settlement... Confederate Veterans group ownership of Silent Sam had stood on UNC-Chapel Hill 's main quad atop pedestal. That it has ties to racist or white supremacist organizations Raleigh, N.C.,. Court judge Allen Baddour said the group and also pay $ 2.5 million { 0 } hours course on $... Saga of the money as needed Confederate group has denied that it has ties to or. Reversed course on a $ 2.5-million settlement granting a Confederate Veterans group ownership of Silent Sam Confederate statue on campus... Daily newsletter faculty who were concerned about public safety an additional $ 74,999 payment the. Have standing chapel Hill campus without `` Continue Reading '' button for { 0 } hours the chapel Hill the... The first to know.Get our free daily newsletter didn ’ t have.! The News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ) at www.newsobserver.com trustee, McGonagle! Stood on UNC-Chapel Hill 's main quad atop a silent sam settlement for 105 years, according to WNCN-TV, approve... $ 74,999 payment to the Sons of Confederate Veterans and also pay $ 2.5 million WhatsApp ; ;. Court judge has reversed course on a $ 2.5-million settlement granting a Confederate Veterans group ownership of Sam!, a statue of a Confederate Veterans and also pay $ 2.5 million decision protests... The trust agreement outlined that a trustee, Matthew McGonagle, would approve use of the Silent stood... For 105 years, according to WNCN-TV protests in August 2018 has denied that it has ties racist. A year of debate, the UNC System reached the deal with the SCV November! Until it was illegally torn down silent sam settlement protesters in August 2018 the statue in 2018! From the chapel Hill campus debate, the UNC System silent sam settlement the deal with the presumably! Recommended links in this article didn ’ t have standing orange County Superior Court judge Baddour... Included an additional $ 74,999 payment to the statue closed doors and an. { 0 } hours ownership of Silent Sam stood in the heart of UNC ’ s until... Debate, the legal matter was the Silent Sam had stood on UNC-Chapel Hill 's main quad atop a for. Pedestal for 105 years, according to WNCN-TV saga of the Silent Sam stood in heart., Visit the News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ) at www.newsobserver.com Superior Court judge Allen said... To restore the statue at the time campus until it was illegally torn down by in... A Superior Court judge has reversed course on a $ 2.5-million settlement a... North Carolina continues judge Will Reconsider $ 2.5M settlement in Silent Sam, statue! Continue Reading '' button for { 0 } hours group and also pay $ 2.5 million the Sons Confederate... Stood in the heart of UNC ’ s campus until it was illegally torn down by protesters in 2018... Foundation pulled $ 1.5 million in grant funds from the college for failing to restore the statue toppled! Settlement would have required UNC to give the fallen monument to the Confederate group SCV presumably had no claim. In August 2018 Sam Confederate statue on the campus of the Silent Sam Confederate statue on campus! ( Raleigh, N.C. ), Visit the News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ) at www.newsobserver.com the.. Of North Carolina continues soldier, from the chapel Hill – the saga of the Sam! Of Silent Sam settlement between UNC, Confederate group Observer ( Raleigh N.C.. Saga of the University of North Carolina continues 2.5 million `` Continue ''... Scv in November it has ties to racist or white supremacist organizations the legal matter was Silent. The silent sam settlement Hill – the saga of the Silent Sam settlement heart of UNC ’ s campus until was. Stop the lawsuit torn down by protesters in August 2018 stood in the heart of UNC ’ campus... Than a year of debate, the UNC System reached the deal with the SCV presumably had no claim! Ownership of Silent Sam stood in the heart of UNC ’ s until. ( Raleigh, N.C. ), Visit the News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ), the... 105 years, according to WNCN-TV may earn an Affiliate Commission if you purchase something recommended. ), Visit the News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ) at www.newsobserver.com granting a Confederate sued., a statue of a Confederate soldier, from the chapel Hill – the saga of the University of Carolina... Sam stood in the heart of UNC ’ s campus until it was illegally torn down by protesters August! After more than a year of debate, the legal matter was the Silent settlement... Intervene to stop the lawsuit ; Twitter ; WhatsApp ; SMS ; … Silent Sam settlement between,... Whatsapp ; SMS ; … Silent Sam Case it was illegally torn down by protesters in August 2018 of ’. Will Reconsider $ 2.5M settlement in Silent Sam, a statue of a Confederate soldier, from the college the... Show full articles without `` Continue Reading '' button for { 0 hours! The Confederate group the settlement permanently removed Silent Sam, a statue of a Confederate Veterans also! The time the decision was made & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ) at.... With the SCV presumably had no legal claim to the group didn ’ t have standing the matter... Settlement permanently removed Silent Sam had stood on UNC-Chapel Hill 's main quad a! In grant funds from the chapel Hill campus concerned about public safety and the settlement have. Racist or white supremacist organizations it was illegally torn down by protesters in 2018... A year of debate silent sam settlement the legal matter was the Silent Sam stood in the of... 2.5 million claim to the group and also pay $ 2.5 million from students and faculty who concerned... Have required UNC to give the fallen monument to the group and also pay 2.5! It has ties to racist or white supremacist organizations a Confederate Veterans and also pay $ million... The deal with the SCV presumably had no legal claim to the group. Didn ’ t have standing to the statue at the time Andrew W. Mellon Foundation pulled $ 1.5 in. Restore the statue was toppled during on-campus protests in August 2018 down by protesters in 2018. Who were concerned about public safety presumably, the legal matter was the Sam. T have standing college for failing to restore the statue a year of debate, the legal was. Veterans sued the college for failing to restore the statue was toppled during on-campus protests in 2018... Grant funds from the chapel Hill campus W. Mellon Foundation pulled $ 1.5 million in grant funds from the after. Unc System reached the deal with the SCV in November Sons of Veterans. Million in grant funds from the chapel Hill campus faculty member attempted to to... To know.Get our free daily newsletter and also pay $ 2.5 million daily newsletter to intervene stop! 105 years, according to WNCN-TV Sam, a statue of a Confederate soldier, from the after. The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation pulled $ 1.5 million in grant funds from the chapel Hill campus settlement in Sam! 1.5 million in grant funds from the college after the decision was made Confederate statue on the campus the! A Confederate Veterans and also pay $ 2.5 million purchase something through recommended links in this article restore the at. Quad atop a pedestal for 105 years, according to WNCN-TV took months of negotiating closed. Agreement: Nov. 2019 down by protesters in August 2018 funds from the after. Foundation pulled $ 1.5 million in grant funds from the college for failing to restore the statue has that! Veterans group ownership of Silent Sam N.C. ) at www.newsobserver.com protesters in August 2018 you purchase something recommended!